Monday, July 27, 2009

The Comedy Cliches

My friend and I recently had a discussion about overused comedy cliches. This topic came up because he was told in a meeting that "How I Met Your Mother" invented the phrase "wait for it" - which of course, is total bullshit. That's like saying Magic Johnson invented the no look pass or the high five or the AIDS.

It's doubtful you can trace the origins of "wait for it". All we know is, it was definitely around since before "How I Met Your Mother" (I remember my friend Susan using it in '03 and it being played out then) and people have been using the shit out of it for years.

There was another comedy cliche in "500 Days of Summer" that I forgot about. It hasn't been used that much recently, but I've seen it a million times. And it always gets a laugh. Always. It never fails. And sure enough, when it happened in "500 Days" the theater cracked up.

It's this one:

Guy finally gets laid, he wakes up in the morning with a shit eating grin and a newfound bounce in his step and some kind of "happy music".

People really love that for some reason. That's how hard up dudes have it, when they finally get some ass blue birds fly on their shoulder. I think the most famous version is from "Big". But there's countless others, and now "500 Days" is added to that illustrious list.

So, the movie...

It was okay, I was a little disappointed. It could've been edited tighter. Also, they shouldn't have given away the ending at the start. It seemed to ruin any surprise and made it feel even longer. Plus, there was a key sequence in the script that was amazing. The little sister says, "when you look back, don't just remember the good things..."

And then we cut to scenes we've already seen but we see them differently. It's pretty powerful the way it was written, and I don't think they pulled it off in the movie version.

Then of course, there was Zooey. Just homely. There's no other word, friends. She is. It's indisputable. And there's this embarrassing sequence where they describe her as setting the record for guy's doing double takes when they see her because of her beauty, and how her sheer gorgeousness caused sales to go up at the store she worked at.

It was the funniest part of the movie.

And here's the big fuck you (at least to me, personally): when I read the script, I thought about the (the million) actresses I'd rather see in the role. Near the top of the list: Minka Kelly. And who appears at the end of the movie? Minka fucking Kelly.

How do you have the nerve to have the girl who should've played Summer be the girl at the end? That's the movie I wanna watch! That's the girl that's out of your league who breaks your heart. Zooey Deschanel is Minka's ugly, quirky friend who you tell your problems to after Minka cheats on you with Riggins. But even you can't complain too much cause Riggins is so awesome, with his tousled hair and devil may care attitude...

All right, I'm getting side tracked by Riggins. But the point is, here's why Zooey Deschanel is my arch nemesis:

I did this google search today: "zooey deschanel unattractive"

And the search came back: "did you mean 'zooey deschanel attractive?'"

Damn you, Deschanel! Stop ruining everything!



p.s. Congratulations to Ed and Jillian, and let me be the first to say: Happy Sexless Marriage!

10 comments:

valeri said...

You know what's weird? I really hated the girl at the end. She was all wrong. There was no way she would date him, ever in a million years. She looked like a model and there was nothing interesting about her. She was just... attractive. That's it. And I think difference in our opinions about Zooey and the movie in general stems from a difference in opinion about beauty.

You seem to like the hot Megan Fox, Minka Kelly (although, I didn't know her name until right now) type chicks. The ones who offer sex appeal and nothing else.

Zooey is (in my opinion, of course) classically beautiful and quirky pretty. She's not "out of my league" pretty, she's approachable pretty. She's not a model, she's a normal person who just happens to be stunning.

I didn't think they gave away the ending at the beginning because (and spoiler alert for everyone reading who hasn't seen it) I kept waiting for her to change her mind about marriage and for him to propose. I think it seemed that way to you because you had read the script first.

On a side note: that little girl is up for the lead in the American re-make of Let the Right One In. Which is a terrible idea. Who is she supposed to be, anyway? His sister?

Irwin Handleman said...

Oh Valeri, I don't think we'll ever agree on this one. But let me give it a shot:

First of all, you're probably right about me having read the script first thing. You can't watch in the same way.

Second, it's not really about me and what I like. The movie hit us over the head, again and again, how "hot" this girl was supposed to be. And you yourself say she's "quirky pretty" and not "out of my league" pretty"...that's not double take/send sales skyrocketing hot. In fact, Tom actually says repeatedly how "out of my league" Summer is. She's not out of anyone's league! She's well placed in normal people's leagues.

Third, Minka only had a couple of lines in the movie, how can you tell that there was "nothing interesting about her"? You have to be homely like Zooey to be interesting? That's racist! Or hotist! Or something with an ist!

Give Minka a chance, she can like the Smith's too.

valeri said...

What? No, I would even go so far as to say Minka's never even heard of the Smiths. In fact, she would like you to listen to the Black Eyes Peas latest album instead of whatever that depressing shit is.

I guess (and this may be because I'm a girl) I figured she was supposed to be beautiful. And she is. I don't recall (and I could be totally wrong) anyone saying the word "hot". Hot in my book means Maxim cover. Playboy cover. Yes, Minka could pull both those off. Zooey isn't Maxim hot. She's... I don't know... Audrey Hepburn beautiful. No one wants to masturbate to her, but no one will deny the fact that she's beautiful (except you, because you are crazy).

I saw it at the Arclight and when I was buying my ticket the guy at the counter went on and on about how it was the second best movie he had seen this year.

Irwin Handleman said...

don't get me wrong, i liked the movie...just didn't love it.

you're right, they never said the word "hot". but the bus thing, the out of my league thing, the sales thing, i mean, that's calling her hot. and if it's calling her beautiful, we agree to disagree on whether she is or isn't (she isn't).

i would say her absolute ceiling is "cute". minka, on the other hand, gets double takes on buses (if she took buses, which she doesn't, cause she's beautiful and can always get rides from people).

Heidi said...

You know, I would really like to fully invest in this debate about "hot" v. "beautiful" and sex appeal v. all around appeal, but now I'm way too busy imagining being in the middle of a Minka/Riggins sandwich, so..... yeah, again some brilliant writing right there. If there is a god in heaven, that Google search line will become 2016's most overused comedy cliche.

(I believe it makes someone's point that I would never consider being anywhere near a Zooey sandwich, even if the other half were Riggins AND Smash.)

Erin said...

Just in case you haven't seen this, EW called "In the Mix" one of the worst rom-coms ever: http://tinyurl.com/lu69wj

Anonymous said...

Really Erin?? You really had to go there? Why do you feel the need to be nasty. You are choosing to read this blog....you certainly don't have to.

Irwin Handleman said...

hey, it's all good. i've always been open and honest about "in the mix" sucking.

heidi, bringing heat! i love it. never thought you'd go smash - god only knows what the steroids did to his junk.

autonomy as a guiding principle said...

I haven't seen the film, so take this for what it's worth (i.e. nothing) but there are those chicks that every guy chases who aren't particularly "hot" but are cute, sometimes not even that. In high school we would call them the whistle that only guys hear. Maybe she was one of those chicks?

I love how ZD ruined your google search. That was funny as hell! I really liked her in The Good Girl as the weirdo, less in Elf as the love interest.

Stephanie said...

Your favorite girl is the celebrity guest on Top Chef Masters next week. Make sure you set your Tivo.